A trial hour without mobile phones in boarding houses has produced board games, long debates, a sudden interest in the library and one boy who stared at the wall for forty minutes waiting for it to refresh
Disconnected
WINDSOR. The great experiment began at seven o’clock on Monday evening, when boys in several boarding houses handed their phones to house staff and placed them in a locked box, where they would remain for one full hour. The trial, part of a wider effort by schools across the country to help teenagers manage screen time, was announced at assembly with the solemnity usually reserved for exam results and the death of a former headmaster.
The reaction among the boys was immediate and dramatic. A lower boy in one house reportedly asked whether the hour would be counted in the same way as a normal hour or whether, as he suspected, it would last significantly longer. A sixth former was overheard saying that he had not been without his phone for an hour since he was eleven, and that he was not sure he remembered how.
The First Ten Minutes
Our correspondent, embedded in one boarding house, observed the first ten minutes with scientific interest. For the first two minutes, boys simply stood in the common room, looking at their empty hands. For the next three minutes, several boys took out their phones out of habit, discovered they were not there and patted their pockets as though searching for a lost relative. One boy sat in an armchair and stared at the wall for forty minutes, apparently waiting for it to refresh. By minute ten, conversation had begun, tentatively, like the first birds after a storm.
What Teenagers Talk About
The conversations, once started, proved lively. According to our observations, the first evening’s topics included the Premier League, in great detail and at high volume; the quality of the toast at breakfast, which was universally condemned; whether a hot dog is a sandwich, which produced the most passionate debate of the hour; and the house football team’s prospects, which were described as poor by realists and excellent by optimists, of whom there were two.
Rajiv Bannerman-Hoyt, the sixth former known as the Cobbler, used the hour to organise an impromptu debate on whether the phone-free hour itself was a good idea. The motion was carried narrowly, which the Cobbler attributed to the fact that the opposition had no way of looking anything up. Without phones, he said, every argument must rely on what you actually know. It is terrifying. It is also wonderful. Half the house discovered tonight that they know nothing about anything. The other half discovered they were right all along.
The Board Game Renaissance
One unexpected consequence of the trial has been a revival of board games. Dusty boxes were pulled from common-room cupboards, some of them apparently untouched since the previous decade. Boys played chess, Scrabble, Risk and a game of Monopoly that, according to witnesses, began at seven and had still not ended at nine, by which time two players were no longer speaking to each other and a third had declared himself a sovereign nation. A house tutor said she had not seen such enthusiasm in years. Boys who usually communicate only in memes were negotiating trade deals over the dark blue properties, she said. It was like watching the Congress of Vienna, but with more shouting.
The Library
The school library reported a noticeable rise in visitors during the phone-free hour. Some came to study, some to read and some, a librarian suspected, simply because the library was warm and had comfortable chairs. Whatever the reason, books were borrowed. One lower boy, previously known for reading nothing longer than a text message, borrowed a novel and returned the next evening to ask whether the author had written anything else. The librarian described this as the high point of her term.
The Science Of Screens
Schools across Britain have been reconsidering how teenagers use smartphones, amid broad public debate about attention, sleep, anxiety and social media. Educators point out that phones are not simply distractions: teenagers use them to stay in touch with family, organise their lives and learn. The aim of a phone-free hour is not to ban technology but to create a little space for other things: conversation, reading, games, rest. A visiting educational psychologist summarised it for this newspaper. Teenagers are not addicted to their phones in some special way, she said. Adults are just as bad. The difference is that teenagers are still learning how to switch off. An hour a day of practice can help.
The Masters React
Several masters have welcomed the experiment, though not all with unqualified enthusiasm. Dr Nigel Thorpe-Willoughby, the veteran history master, said he supported it fully and suggested that the phone-free hour be extended to the entire day, the whole of the half and, ideally, the rest of the century. Asked whether he himself owned a smartphone, he produced a small grey device from his pocket that appeared to have been manufactured before colour screens existed. It makes calls, he said. It sends messages, slowly. It cannot connect to anything. It is the finest piece of technology I have ever owned.
The Verdict
After one week, the boys’ verdict on the trial is mixed but surprisingly positive. Many say they missed their phones intensely for the first two days and barely thought about them by the fifth. Several report sleeping better. A few say they have made friends with boys in their own house whom they had previously only known as profile pictures. One fifth former said the hour had changed his perspective. I used to think I was bored without my phone, he said. It turns out I was only bored with my phone. Without it, I am too busy losing at chess to be bored.
What Comes Next
The school will review the trial at the end of the half, gathering feedback from boys, staff and parents. If it continues, house staff have suggested activities to fill the hour, including debates, music practice, reading groups and, at the request of several boys, a toast improvement committee to address the breakfast situation. The Cobbler has volunteered to chair it.
The Last Word
At eight o’clock on Friday evening, the box was unlocked and the phones were handed back. Boys seized them eagerly, unlocked them and scrolled through an hour of missed notifications. Within a minute, the common room had fallen silent again, every face lit by a small glowing screen. Then, from the corner, a voice called out. Hang on, said a lower boy, looking up from his phone. We never finished the Monopoly. Slowly, one by one, the boys put their phones in their pockets and drifted back to the board, where the dark blue properties still sat unclaimed. They played until lights out. Nobody checked their phone once.
The London Prat
Scriptor Rerum Novarum Cupidus: Morag Sinclair